Why the Garth Brooks Facebook Video Fell Flat

By Victoria Stoklasa, CEO

If you haven't watched Garth Brooks's video announcing that he is finally on Facebook, you should. In fact, you should watch it twenty times in a row, so you can fully absorb all it's glory. We'll even provide the video for you to watch. Go ahead...I can wait.

Whether or not you're a fan of Garth's music, it's hard to deny that there are certain things about this video that are just off. This is our goal: We want to teach you everything that is wrong with this video, so that you and your company won't make the same mistakes.

It Feels Fake

Garth comments in his video that he wants to post "cool stuff, slick stuff, neat stuff" on his Facebook page, but that he also wants to post "raw stuff, like this [video]. This is just who I am." Here's the thing: The video doesn't actually feel raw. It's obviously a rehearsed script. That makes the entire experience feel insincere. Our advice to Mr. Brooks would be that he shouldn't be afraid of going off script. His fans love him and are devoted to him, and they would be overjoyed to feel as if he is really letting them into his life

It's a Little Creepy

This video has moments that make Garth Brooks feel less like a country music superstar and more like that creepy guy at the country music bar. The rehearsed delivery makes it feel as though he's feeding the viewer pick-up lines like, "Did it hurt when you fell from Heaven, angel?" When he says that Facebook is "wiping the walls out between you and me, and I really like that," it goes from being inclusive to being invasive. We would have loved to see him change the rhetoric so that it's less about putting himself into people's lives, and more about how he's letting others into his life. (Don't even get us started on how this video takes place in a dimly-lit hotel room.)

What He Got Right

As much as we might be ripping this video apart, it isn't a complete failure. One of the comments Garth makes is that a friend told him to "think of [Facebook] more as a conversation." At Bon Visto Media, we wholeheartedly agree--there's a reason that social media has the word "social" in it. If he takes this to heart, then Garth Brooks could be incredibly successful on Facebook. This would mean being accessible, genuine, and responsive to comments. 

What do you think of Garth Brooks's video? Let us know in the comments!